Sign In | Create an Account | Welcome, . My Account | Logout | Subscribe | Submit News | Facebook | Twitter | Home RSS
 
 
 

'Dance Moms' tramples kids' esteem

July 14, 2011 - Erin O'Neill
If you have been unfortunate enough to tune into the train wreck that is the new Lifetime reality show, "Dance Moms," you no doubt witnessed the requisite screaming, catfighting pile of garbage that we consider "normal" entertainment these days.

I had seen the previews and I tuned in probably for the same reason as most others. I wanted to see just how crazy it was going to be. In that respect, it didn't disappoint. I view reality TV anymore as loosely scripted shock TV — TV designed to make you crane your neck at the carnage.

But I also tuned in because, I guess, in theory, I am a dance mom. My kid doesn't compete but dance classes have been a part of our lives for the past two seasons and we are ready to start our third. I researched the plethora of dance schools in the area and settled on Marietta Dance Academy. I have been super pleased with the instructors, the lessons my child is being taught about self worth, getting along and working with others, and allowing her creativity to blossom. The affordability factor also doesn't hurt. I mean, Amy Lee, the subject of "Dance Moms" charges $16,000 a year. How insane is that!?

Now I have no doubt that there are some crazy, "pageant mom"-types in the dance world, as portrayed in the show. I know there are divas everywhere, from the stage to the soccer field to the classroom. Thankfully, I haven't come across any - so far. Mostly they suffer from a lack of self-esteem and are living out their failed dreams through their children. Others - I count myself in this category - simply want their child to be well-rounded, to experience many different aspects in life to be able to make bigger life decisions down the road. At least that's what I tell myself. I keep promising myself that if my child shows she isn't the least bit interested in anything we try, I will let her move on to something else. Whether or not I stand by that is another story for another day.

Anyway, pushy dance moms aside (and the moms on the show actually step up to confront the teacher on several occasions), the real villainess is the owner and instructor, Abby Lee Miller. I guess she is world-renowned for producing superstars. Whatever. I could care less about the woman and her claim to fame. In my view, she is a bully and abusive to the students and the parents who are footing the bill. Sure, the parents make the decision to send their kids there. That's totally on them. But to witness the way she treats the young girls, it literally made me sick to my stomach.

Since when is winning more important than building confidence and positive relationships? Why must girls be pitted against each other in a battle to "reign" supreme (no surprise, "reign dance" is the name of her company). I half expected to hear negative comments about the tween girls' weight but I guess Lifetime thought that would be going too far. Sure, everyone likes to excel at something and competition isn't necessarily a bad thing. But there are ways to positively encourage children to succeed. The most influential teachers I ever had were caring and nurturing. The ones who were pushy and mean, well they succeeded at nothing other than to make me resent them.

The "Dance Moms" show serves its purpose as shock-tainment, and, despite comments to the contrary, people will continue to tune in to see the horror show. And I will even give Abby Lee the benefit of the doubt to say the editors left big chunks of "reality" on the cutting room floor to elicit specific reactions. But the idea behind the show gives dance instructors and dance moms a bad name. As I have witnessed, the teacher-parent-child relationship is very important in any extracurricular or creative activity and is essential to growing a child who is secure in themselves.

I am grateful that my child has been able to experience the beauty and joyfulness of dance without all the drama. And if the day ever comes that the drama outweighs the benefits, my daughter and I will be tap dancing out the door.

 
 

Article Comments

(9)

jaymus777

Dec-26-11 7:50 PM

what i dont understand is why this abby has to be so rude and mean to the kids it is one thing to be tough on students and teach discipline it is another to ridicule and tear them down she is destroying their self esteem and how in the world can abby be a dance instructor when she weighs 2 tons my god she has to turn side ways to get through a door way how can you teach someone to do something if you cant even do it your self how can a instructor tech if they can not demonstrate how to perform what ever they are teaching abby your a loud mouth fat A$# trailor trash ******* hick go back to the trailer court where you belong

Sep-13-11 1:06 PM

Miss Abby is tough and she could have more finesse, but it is MOM's responsibility to build self-esteem and the "soft fuzzies". And if MOM finds it "abusive", then MOM needs to move baby girl. The show tries to paint Miss Abby as the villain, but she is upfront and says "this is business and my business is molding successful dancers". The most disgusting part about the whole show is the catty moms who argue with each other and the teacher in front of their children. Abby has been guilty of putting the kids in the middle also, but the Moms truly disgust me more than anything b/c they are setting a terrible example for their children when they act like that. Also, there are places for kids to go have fun dancing and enjoy it and there are places for kids who want to be professional. Just like there are baseball teams for boys who just want to play and there are serious competition teams for those who want to play MLB - and I can guarantee you the coaches pr

mmcleod

Aug-22-11 12:19 AM

I've read a few comments from other news sites too, and I have to say, if you're expecting a nice dance teacher your child probably won't succeed. Abby Lee is not physically or mentally abusing these children, she is preparing them for the real world. If you suck, Hollywood and New York has no problem shutting the doors in your face. Same with college, if you don't work hard for your grades in HS, then in college you will fail and the professor will not care. These parents want their daughters to be successful, and there is no reason why they can't grow thick skin through the learning process. If you*****and don't work hard, you are in the back of the routine and probably wont make it in the real world.

clover1013

Aug-05-11 6:44 PM

That should have said 2 solos not 23..

clover1013

Aug-05-11 6:43 PM

I ran a studio for over a decade and many of my students won regional and national dance title, we won choreography awards, special awards, and overall scores. And never once did I ever have to make a child cry, yell, scream, or hurt the child's self esteem. Many of my students are dancing professionally, own their own studios, or are teaching now. I think a lot of this show is fake. No studio owner only spends time with 6 or 7 girls. They take all their competition groups & solos to competitions. And that one mom who had a fit over Maddy doing 23 solos that was ridiculous! She should be happy she was given a solo especially since she doesn't pay for a private. I mean ..who does that? Plus, if Maddy didn't beat her some other child would have. These mothers are probably paid good money to create all this extra drama. I feel bad for these children.

Jul-17-11 10:21 PM

As a former dancer, I am going to say something that is unpopular. Your article simply proves that the Abby Lee Dance Company isn't for you. It is not a frilly "let's dance for fun!" studio. It is one focused on making the next generation of professional dancers. And that doesn't happen with the "let's focus on getting along" method you seem to prefer. It happens with more of a "tiger mom" method. Kids are gonna cry, get restless, and want to quit. I often wonder why parents let them! In order to be winning dancers, they need an instructor who won't tolerate it. $16k per year? That tuition is the norm for those serious about pursuing scholarships, competitions, and professional careers. I grew the most as a dancer with a teacher like Abby. My advice is my mom's approach: when I was crying at 12 after rehearsal, mom told me I was at the level where dance was no longer a fun hobby, but a skill to be studied seriously. It was my choice to continue, but I

eoneill

Jul-16-11 11:31 AM

memerose579: Thank you for the comment! If you are local and have been involved with this woman I would love to talk to you about the experience. Maybe a story down the road?

However, I must respectfully say that I think, even if the editors are manipulating every shot we see on the screen and it in no way accurately represents the woman, her students, the parents or her studio, she is still guilty of making a very poor decision in the way she wants to market herself, her school and the competitive dancing world by agreeing to do such a show in the first place.

And if those words come out of her mouth even ONE time, she is not worthy of molding young minds. No one should ever talk to children that way...not in a classroom, a dance studio or a football field.

memerose579

Jul-16-11 8:28 AM

You could not be more incorrect. I know for a fact that she IS a great dance teacher. I had the privilege of dancing for her for 5 years and she is still one of the most influential people i my life. I was an ugly , knobby kneed twelve year old and she told me that I was beautiful and gave me the confidence I needed. She was NEVER discouraging, she pushed everyone to be the best the could possibly be. her classes were hard, but they left you feeling satisfied knowing you had worked your butt off. She is one of the best dance teachers in the country. The girls at her studio love dance and are extremely supportive of each other. Don't assume that you know everything about the studio because you have seen a small glimpse.

njtktr3

Jul-14-11 3:31 PM

I totally agree. My family was appalled by the behavior exhibited on that show. I wouldn't treat my animals the way those children were being treated. And the mothers were allowing this? I cannot comprehend what kind of parent thinks this is a way to build their child's character. It's teaching them to be spiteful, resentful, and rude. I am so glad that the dance family at Marietta Dance Academy is the polar opposite of this show. We truly are a "family". Everyone gets praise and encouragement, no matter what their talent level may be. I teach my children and my students to respect everyone and support each other. I am proud to say that the poor behavior shown on that show is not tolerated at Marietta Dance Academy.

 
 

Post a Comment

You must first login before you can comment.

*Your email address:
*Password:
Remember my email address.
or
 
 

 

I am looking for:
in:
News, Blogs & Events Web
 
 

Blog Photos

A student and one of the crazy moms from "Dance Moms" on Lifetime.